Level 1 — Absolute Beginner
Egypt is a very old country. About 5,000 years ago, it has its first kings. When a king dies, people put him in a big tomb in the sand.
Many other people are in the ground near each king. They are his servants. For a long time, nobody knows how they died.
Now a scientist looks at 46 old skulls. A skull is the bone of the head. The skulls come from the tombs of the first kings.
She finds something sad. Eighteen skulls are broken. Somebody hit these people on the head. The scientist thinks the servants were killed to go with their king.
- kings
- Men who rule a country.
- tomb
- A place where a dead person is put.
- sand
- Very small pieces of rock in a desert or on a beach.
- servants
- People who work for an important person.
- scientist
- A person who studies the world carefully.
- skulls
- The bones of heads.
- bone
- A hard white part inside the body.
- broken
- In pieces or damaged.
Level 2 — Elementary
Egypt's first kings ruled about 5,000 years ago, long before the pyramids were built. They were buried at a place called Abydos, and each royal tomb was surrounded by the graves of many servants. Archaeologists have argued for a hundred years about how those servants died.
A new study gives a clear and dark answer for some of them. Roselyn Campbell, a researcher at Purdue University in the United States, examined 46 skulls from the tombs. She found that 18 of them had serious injuries that probably caused death.
The skulls were dug up more than a century ago by the British archaeologist Flinders Petrie. He put most of the bodies back in the ground but kept the skulls and sent some to Britain. Campbell found them in a collection at the University of Cambridge. Petrie had seen the cracks in the bone, but he seems to have thought they were natural damage.
Using modern methods, Campbell showed that the cracks came from hard blows to the head. She believes the servants were killed so that they could serve the king after death. The study does not say what weapon was used, and it cannot tell us how the other servants died.
- ruled
- Led a country as king or queen.
- pyramids
- Huge stone buildings with four sides that meet at a point, built in ancient Egypt.
- buried
- Put in the ground after death.
- archaeologists
- People who study the past by digging up old objects and buildings.
- examined
- Looked at something very carefully.
- injuries
- Damage to a person's body.
- collection
- A group of objects that are kept together.
- weapon
- An object used to hurt or kill.
Level 3 — Intermediate
For a century, Egyptologists have debated whether the servants buried around the tombs of Egypt's earliest kings were deliberately killed. A forensic re-examination of their skulls now provides the strongest physical evidence yet that many of them were. The research, led by Roselyn Campbell of Purdue University, appears in the journal Frontiers in Environmental Archaeology and has drawn renewed attention this month.
The remains come from the First Dynasty royal cemetery at Abydos, which is roughly 5,000 years old and predates the pyramids. When Flinders Petrie excavated the site, he reburied most of the skeletons but retained the skulls, shipping some to Britain. Campbell traced 46 of them to the Duckworth Collection at the University of Cambridge.
Eighteen of the 46 showed significant trauma, mostly linear fractures that Petrie apparently mistook for natural damage. A few bore the marks of sharp blades as well, including a chopping wound near one individual's eye. Campbell concludes that at least 39 percent of the people in the sample may have been killed by blows to the head, which fits the theory that retainers were sacrificed to accompany their ruler.
The study is careful about its limits. The fractures do not match the dents that a mace would normally leave, so the weapon is unknown. Nor does the work support Petrie's most dramatic suggestion, made in the 1920s, that some servants were buried alive. And since only the surviving skulls could be studied, the fate of the hundreds of other people interred beside the kings remains uncertain.
- deliberately
- On purpose, not by accident.
- forensic
- Using scientific methods to investigate how someone died.
- predates
- Is older than something else.
- excavated
- Dug up carefully in order to study the past.
- retained
- Kept instead of giving away or returning.
- trauma
- Serious physical injury.
- fractures
- Breaks or cracks in a bone.
- sacrificed
- Killed as part of a religious act.
Level 4 — Advanced
The first pharaohs did not go into the afterlife alone. Around their mud-brick tombs at Abydos, raised some five millennia ago, lie neat rows of subsidiary graves holding courtiers, attendants and craftsmen by the hundred. That so many people should have died in step with their sovereign has long smelled of coercion, but suspicion is not proof, and for a century the charge of ritual killing rested on inference alone.
Roselyn Campbell, a bioarchaeologist at Purdue University, has now supplied something more tangible. Writing in Frontiers in Environmental Archaeology, she reports a forensic reappraisal of 46 crania that Flinders Petrie removed from the First Dynasty cemetery and that ended up in the Duckworth Collection at Cambridge. Petrie reinterred the rest of the skeletons, an act of tidiness that modern researchers have had cause to regret.
Eighteen of the skulls carry significant trauma inflicted around the time of death. Most are linear fractures of the sort Petrie seems to have dismissed as the ordinary wear of burial; a handful show sharp-force wounds, among them a chopping blow beside an eye. On Campbell's reading, at least 39 percent of the individuals sampled may have been dispatched by strikes to the head, a pattern difficult to reconcile with accident, epidemic or battle.
The paper is conspicuously unwilling to overreach. The fractures are not the depressed, crater-like injuries that a mace typically produces, so the instrument of death remains unidentified. Petrie's own lurid conjecture, floated in the 1920s, that retainers were entombed while still breathing, finds no support here. And 46 skulls are a sliver of the cemetery's population, selected by the accidents of preservation and of one Edwardian excavator's packing crates.
Even so, the findings sharpen a paradox at the birth of the Egyptian state. Retainer sacrifice appears with the earliest kings and disappears within a few generations, replaced in later tombs by small figurines that served as symbolic substitutes. A practice that advertised a ruler's absolute command over life seems to have proved too costly, or too abhorrent, to keep.
- subsidiary
- Connected to something larger but less important than it.
- coercion
- The use of force or threats to make people do something.
- inference
- A conclusion reached from evidence and reasoning rather than direct proof.
- tangible
- Real and able to be seen or touched.
- reappraisal
- A new examination of something in order to judge it again.
- reinterred
- Buried again.
- conjecture
- An opinion formed without firm evidence.
- abhorrent
- Causing strong moral disgust.